Why Would They Falsely Confess? + J" j8 p* ~' f/ V" v! Z
Why on earth would an innocent person falsely confess to committing a crime? To most people, it just doesnt seem logical. But it is logical, say experts, if you understand what can happen in a police interrogation (审讯) room.
" j t p' Z0 a1 m8 ~8 Y6 b Under the right conditions, peoples minds are susceptible (易受影响的) to influence, and the pressure put on suspects during police questioning is enormous. 46 “The pressure is important to understand, because otherwise its impossible to understand why someone would say he did something he didnt do. The answer is: to put an end to an uncomfortable situation that will continue until he does confess.”
! m$ n6 G6 D& Q+ D$ ~1 H Developmental psychologist Mary Redlich recently conducted a laboratory study to determine how likely people are to confess to things they didnt do. 47 The researchers then intentionally crashed the computers and accused the participants of hitting the “alt” key to see if they would sign a statement falsely taking responsibility.
/ y- _# X/ a& Q- `4 c/ X u Redlich’s findings clearly demonstrate how easy it can be to get people to falsely confess: 59 percent of the young adults in the experiment immediately confessed. 48 Of the 15 to 16 yearolds, 72 percent signed confessions, as did 78 percent of the 12 to 13 year olds. + \/ v3 M/ `. `( k( ]
“Theres no question that young people are more at risk,”says Saul Kassin, a psychology professor at Williams College, who has done similar studies with similar results. 49
" B' Z8 d' k/ F8 N4 q) N4 |' q. hBoth Kassin and Redlich note that the entire “interrogation” in their experiments consisted of a simple accusation—not hours of aggressive questioning—and still, most participants falsely confessed. 7 t" y# P* A: ^- k: N+ T, z! M. u) T( x
50 “In some ways,”says Kassin, “false confession becomes a rational decision.” $ ~- a$ G& h8 K( n$ p
A In her experiment, participants were seated at computers and told not to hit the “alt” key,
2 h8 A& x a' a7 X' t5 C7 ] because doing so would crash the systems. Y" `7 x! c# x+ e0 V
B Because of the stress of a police interrogation, they conclude, suspects can become
3 i& G5 F" w6 E' x+ w' m2 L- D convinced that falsely confessing is the easiest way out of a bad situation.
1 H0 b; b5 C. r) a; P- y% e9 R$ y. O C “Its a little like somebodys working on them with a dental (牙齿的) drill,”says + w2 [; D# r4 H: q
Franklin Zimring, a law professor at the University of California at Berkeley.
: l) T9 f1 M D D “But the baseline is that adults are highly vulnerable too.” 4 E) |: _- H) |+ O
E The court found him innocent and he was released.
1 \ i- J" j/ z F Redlich also found that the younger the participant, the more likely a false confession. 7 C/ l+ ]% L! U/ a" q6 \ D
46.C47.A48.F49.D50.B |
发表于 2012-8-15 23:30:26
