Jean: Studies show that professional engineers whose first job assignment is highly / n. X/ t3 q+ I) [" O
challenging tend to perform more successfully on subsequent assignments over
& S% `3 I: o# I7 W+ {/ ] the next five years than do engineers whose first assignment is less challenging. : R; `/ v3 A/ ~) {& `: v
Presumably, high-challenge tasks lead engineers to develop professional skills
/ i/ U+ {3 @* ] that serve to raise their performance level on subsequent assignments. 0 X0 @5 s& _; m; Y$ [. i7 i$ D
* Y7 l0 \0 O$ N9 M4 tPat: But perhaps engineers who are given challenging first assignments are precisely
. S8 x7 y& b) f- q" ^( @9 W6 t( j4 X those who are judged to be most able.
$ p! I, e4 ?8 I. F; P1 v 3 H/ S! P9 I9 o$ B$ @4 C& [4 M8 x
Which of the following, if true, would be the strongest counter for Jean to make to Pat’s " p1 X0 d) ^. g7 F' G+ k
objection? ) P S3 v; l. x* [: m
1 i- s' P1 ^# |( x$ n" z
1 j! K" e5 i! X0 |
A Among engineers judged to be equally able, those whose first assignment is highly
& ~4 n( P0 x/ {, F" V. ~ challenging perform more successfully on subsequent assignments than do those
2 j; [9 E* a& z! L2 {6 M whose first assignment is less challenging. 3 D m- m* Z9 @
B Even some of the engineers whose first assignment is not very challenging neverthe- ! H6 v$ a, h9 k: Y
less develop their professional skills through performing that assignment.
, t3 H, Z; v* ^7 S1 ] C The engineers who successfully carry out their first assignment are to a large degree
8 n9 X2 P! i7 x2 K3 V s- ]$ e; F( a those who were initially judged to have the greatest ability.
# P2 C/ n6 q6 d& r" ^/ ?9 c; ^% Y D The rate of successful completion is lower for the least challenging first assignments
4 N" o! K6 _$ W3 N than it is for the most challenging first assignments.
a4 y" O1 j/ _. ]4 @ E Among engineers whose first assignment is not very challenging, those who success- " i4 {2 v+ N0 [ H' E/ y, p/ n
8 K: L9 X' H% T1 P! ` fully carry out that first assignment are more likely to be given highly challenging
- a# u) x9 p$ y6 D% a/ u subsequent assignments. 0 B7 i6 N& A4 g! ]$ P$ q
答案:A |